CALL: (866) 913-5810
Apple Cider Made the Old Fashioned Way
256 E Main Street, Penn Yan, NY 14527-8947

Hours of Operation: August- December Monday–Saturday, 7:30 a.m.–6:00 p.m., Sunday 8 a.m.–5 p.m.
Opening for the 2016 Season August 26, 2016

Service Area: Rochester, Corning, Elmira, Ithaca, Hornell


Fresh Apples at Their Very Best

                                          Old Fashioned Apple Cider

Make Wager's Cider Mill of Penn Yan, New York, your apple cider source. We make cider the way it should be made, the old fashioned way. Enjoy our farm fresh apples, cider, donuts, and grape juice.

Apple Tree, Fresh Apples in Penn Yan, NY

Old-Fashioned Way of Making Cider
We wash and grind the apples, make up the rack, and cloth press which was the original system of processing. Ultra-violet process used from apples grown on our own farm. We have experience making apple cider the old fashioned way for over 57 years.

We Specialize in the Following:
Apple Cider • Fresh Apples • Grape Juice • Apple Cider Donuts

Giving You and Your Family the Very Best
Our experience says it all. We have been at this for a long time and you can trust our cider to taste like it should and just how you remember as a young child. Bring your family to us to taste old fashioned cider at its best.

About Us
Since 1929 our building has been a cider mill and juice plant. The cider press was brought from Geneva, NY, where it originated in 1883. The business has been family owned and operated since 1974. Feel free to come watch the apple cider get processed on site.

Contact us to see the old-fashioned way of making apple cider from farm fresh apples.